UC Law Journal of Race and Economic Justice
Abstract
Donald Trump’s second presidency has sparked outrage amongst millions of Americans. Many members of the American legal community have spoken out, releasing statements and letters denouncing the administration’s actions. The dominant response among lawyers, law professors, and bar associations has been to declare a constitutional crisis, defend the rule of law, and call for preserving the status quo. This response amounts to restorationism—a call to return to the pre-Trump institutional past.
This Article firmly rejects restorationism and asserts that the legal community’s dominant response, although legally correct and undoubtedly well-intentioned, is significantly flawed. It manifests a popular mode of argument that features unqualified valorizations of the rule of law, ignores decades-old racial critiques of rule-of-law principles, and consequently promotes a vision of American democracy that is dismissive of the lives and struggles of racial minorities, especially Black people. This Article illustrates this point through analysis of, and analogy to, Abraham Lincoln’s first inaugural address, in which he denounced the parties responsible for the constitutional crisis of his day but indicated his comfort with the proslavery rule of law and status quo. In that address, Lincoln’s mode of argument displayed a serious indifference to Black lives that the American legal community’s response has eerily replicated in its condemnation of Trump. To both avoid this indifference and properly contextualize the times, denunciations of the present constitutional crisis—as well as any future crises—should incorporate racial critiques of the rule of law and an indictment of American racism.
Recommended Citation
Zamir Ben-Dan,
Against Restorationism,
24 UC Law SF Race & Econ. Just. L.J. 3
(2026).
Available at: https://repository.uclawsf.edu/hastings_race_poverty_law_journal/vol24/iss1/3